Mortgage Comparison Calculator
To compare two mortgages, look at three numbers for each: the monthly principal and interest payment, the total interest paid over the full term, and the upfront costs. A lower rate or shorter term cuts total interest, while a longer term lowers the monthly payment. The cheaper loan depends on how long the borrower keeps it.
Loan B costs less overall
$326,838.20
Difference in interest plus upfront costs if each loan is kept to the end of its term.
- Loan A payment
- $2,661.21
- Loan B payment
- $3,484.43
- Loan A total interest
- $558,035.60
- Loan B total interest
- $227,197.40
- Loan A total cost
- $561,035.60
- Loan B total cost
- $234,197.40
Estimates only. This calculator is for comparison and education. It is not a Loan Estimate, a commitment to lend, or financial advice.
How it is calculated
Payment = principal and interest at the loan's rate and term. Total interest = payment x number of payments - loan amount. Total cost = total interest + upfront costs.
Worked example
Loan A is $400,000 at 7.000% for 30 years with $3,000 in costs: $2,661.21 a month and $561,035.60 in total cost. Loan B is $400,000 at 6.500% for 15 years with $7,000 in costs: $3,484.43 a month and $234,197.40 in total cost. Loan B costs $823.22 more each month and $326,838.20 less overall.
Questions
How do I compare two mortgage offers?
Line up the loan amount, rate, term and upfront costs for each, then compare the monthly payment and the total cost. Compare offers for the same loan amount and on the same day, because rates change daily.
Is the lowest rate always the best mortgage?
No. A lower rate often comes with higher upfront costs. If the borrower sells or refinances early, the loan with lower costs and a slightly higher rate can be cheaper.
Should I compare APR or interest rate?
Both. The interest rate sets the payment. APR spreads certain upfront finance charges over the loan term, so it helps compare offers with different fees, but it assumes the loan is kept to maturity.
Is a 15-year mortgage cheaper than a 30-year?
In total interest, usually yes, because the balance is repaid faster and the rate is often lower. The monthly payment is higher.
For loan officers
Send this to your client as a branded proposal.
This is what Mortgage Proposal does for a living: several options side by side with payment, APR, cash to close and break-even, under your brand. Your logo, your numbers, ready to email in about two minutes.
Start freeFree for 5 proposals a month. No card.